So, there's usually a .20 to .30 difference between the lowest grade and the highest grade of gas- all other things being equal. Assuming that your car averages 20 mpg, doesn't it seem peculiar to get crappy performance from a $30k-40k muscle car for what works out to a .01 to .015 a mile price difference? Assuming a .30 price diff between low octane and high octane, the upfront cost of running premium for 15k miles (a nice round calculation for a year's driving) is $225 (15k/20mpg x .30 price diff). Same logic holds for buying quality gas (Chevron, Shell, Texaco, Exxon, etc...) rather than crappo 7-11 drudge.
