Briefly, it boils down to the Scat Pack is a more balanced car than the Hellcat. The Hellcat's got muscle to spare but not much else. It got to the point I really wasn't enjoying the car as much as I should have given what it cost.
The SP feels more sporty and is more fun to drive especially on roads with curves which abound here in Benton County AR.
Also, the Hellcat is a complex car with the supercharger, its drive, the intake charge cooling system, A8, and uConnect radio stuff. Had the NAV go out last July. Took hours at the dealer -- two different times -- for the radio to be confirmed bad and 2 different software updates tried. Neither one helped. Then a 3rd visit to get the radio replaced. Yes, under warranty but that was July last year. Hellcat is out of warranty IIRC the 17th of this month. Just decided I didn't want to own a complex car out of warranty.
Really enjoying the Scat Pack. Or was. Was in the shop for several weeks getting some body damage fixed after being hit -- it was parked -- by somebody pulling out of the parking space next to it.
Pic:
Car repaired. Damage total came to $8007. I picked the car up around 6pm Friday Feb. 5. Drove it 20+ miles home. Weather has been so bad I have only driven it twice since then. The other day it was in 12F cold.
A pic taken yesterday (IIRC):
Currently it is 0F with a wind chill of -17F and snow forecast for today. Probably not even taking my van out. Might walk to the mail box and pick up mail later today. Round trip is probably 200ft.