What year is your car? The 2014- and the 2015+ are wired different.

Anywho, my unkind guess is that you have a 2015+ and the two dimmer knobs by the headlight switch, the one for the interior lights is turned all the way down.

 

Should have specified, 2015 ScatPack.

There’s the 2 dials, one for gauge lighting and one for the “ambient” lighting.
When I turn the gauge lighting all the way up, all interior lights come on.

The other one adjusts the brightness of the little lights in the door panels, but has no effect on the map lights..

 

I have a 2016, and I can tell you, pushing those map light lenses does nothing unless the engine is running, or you are in accessory mode. You can't just get in your car and push a lens and have it stay lit.
I'm not sure if I helped things, or confused you more.

 

Yes, I am talking about with engine running.

 

I'm having the same issue right now on my 2022 scatpack charger after a shop installed a starlight roof. Did you ever figure out what the issue was?

 

Welcome to Challengertalk Will the shop not fix their mistake? There is a connector to the Overhead Module, I'd check the connector and harness. Either something unplugged, wire pulled back in connector, crimped, damaged

A Guy