Dodge Challenger Forum banner

Original tires matter on a rare car?

3.4K views 19 replies 15 participants last post by  WXman  
#1 ·
Hi all. I know this may be very opinion based question I have on tires but here it goes. I'm in the process of buying a 2010 R/T classic 6 spd with the STP option that came with the Goodyear f1 supercar tires. The car only has 29000 km not sure mile 18000? but due to age these tires are due for safety. I am in Canada and don't plan on driving winter but spring and fall does often fall below 50 degrees frequently below 40 early AM or PM. Part of me wants to keep this car original (since it is) and part wants a decent all season performance tire. I recently put a set of Continental extreme contact DWS 6 on my Infiniti, seems decent though literally still brand new. What are peoples thoughts on this? Should a rare car be kept as original as possible, even up to and including tire brand/model? Thanks!
 
#7 ·
There are cars and more importantly, shows where originality matters, but even these normally allow for reproduction tires.

With that said, we are talking about a completely different automotive circle than the modern Challenger moves in.

Even from a styling standpoint these are just black wall tires. It's not like they are a styling feature of the car.

I wanted my 68 Formula S, to look stock so I bought reproduction biasply redlines for it, but the redlines were a styling feature.
 
#8 · (Edited)
Modern Challengers are not rare. Since 2008, Dodge has built over 500,000. The only ones that may substantially appreciate are the limited edition, high horsepower models like the SRT Demon, Super Stock, Jailbreak, Redeye and Hellcat.

As a comparison, only 165,437 Challengers were built between 1970-1974 and almost all were daily drivers. Back then very few owners thought to save them.

Put on any tires of your choice that will perform well.
 
#9 ·
Yes I guess I was overthinking that lol. Maybe I worded it weird but I didn't mean I'd keep the 12 year old tires I meant new ones of the same type. The thought of softer tires that wear out quicker and are not all season in Canada seems like a bad idea anyways. Its good to know that most of us won't flame someone for not having "original" equipment. Maybe that's a vette owners club thing? Kind of a stupid question really when everybody just mods these things lol.

Ya ill go with the DWS6 or equivalent. Thanks for all the replies. Ill be sure to post pics up when the deal is done.

I sold my 2014 SRT8 last fall before storing it and its been just killing me to rectify the mistake I made.
 
#11 ·
Major factor in the Paul Walker death, two of the tires being more than nine years old and all probably hard with vastly reduced traction.


Sent from my SM-N960U using Tapatalk
 
#12 ·
As a former owner of a car that came stock with GY supercar tires (2015 Camaro 1LE) I'm beyond shocked that the tires had that many miles on them. I only got about 12,000 miles out of mine. Granted, that included several road course races/play days, but still.
For replacements, I can first hand reccomend the Conti DSW, as well as the Michelin PS4S, although different cars than challengers. Once the stock pirelli on my spwb wear, one of the 2 listed above will be installed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Craag
#13 ·
As a former owner of a car that came stock with GY supercar tires (2015 Camaro 1LE) I'm beyond shocked that the tires had that many miles on them. I only got about 12,000 miles out of mine. Granted, that included several road course races/play days, but still.
For replacements, I can first hand reccomend the Conti DSW, as well as the Michelin PS4S, although different cars than challengers. Once the stock pirelli on my spwb wear, one of the 2 listed above will be installed.
Yes the pirellis on my 14 srt8 didn't wear too well. Not a fan. I doubt the owners of this car ever tracked it or drove anything more than some "spirited" fun driving. Unfortunately the owner had health issues the last 4 years or so hence the low mileage.
 
#14 ·
My car collector neighbor used to save his original tires but it did not affect the value of any car he sold. IF you have the room I guess you could save them, just for grins. Otherwise, don't worry about it. I kept my original spare from my 1974 AMC Matador X when I owned it. It dresses up the trunk area at shows but as far as affecting value? Nope...

Image
 
  • Like
Reactions: Craag
#15 ·
Tire Stickers or Coker Tire either way you can get the Vintage Reproduction look. There is always ways to do Vintage Style Tires...
Image


You can even get the Eagle F1's still by Goodyear
 
#16 ·
Well, any use of summer tires should be 100% ruled out in CA. I had a '10 R/T Classic with the Goodyear summer tires on and I dreaded driving below 50 F since the tires got very hard and slipped around fast turns (highway entrance and exit ramps) or from a standing start. I'm in FL now and still won't ever consider them just in case I have to drive up north in the mountains in colder weather.
I don't see any loss in value by not keeping original style tires on it. The next buyer can always replace them if they want to.
 
#17 ·
go with the Conti DWS06 (now Plus) - they're far better performing than the GY F1s and you can drive year-round without even having to consider the temperatures
 
#18 ·
Haven't read all the posts and maybe this has been covered...

I doubt the car is going to be made any more valuable by having original tires. If you believe it would be more valuable with original tires one has to wonder what would adding any more miles to odometer do to car's future value?

If you want to hedge your bet regarding the car's future value you can always remove the original wheels/tires and store them wrapped in plastic. Then buy a set of suitable wheels fitted with proper new and safe tires to use if you intend to drive the car.
 
#20 ·
I had the same question. My '11 came with the Goodyear F1s. They're already long gone, replaced by General A/S tires. Since this car is apparently one of one according to Dodge I wondered if it would be worth it to put Goodyear F1s back on it.

But I think what I'm going to do instead is look for a wider UHP A/S tire. I've tried summer tires by Mickey Thompson and Nitto in the past with horrible results. Unless it's 90 degrees outside they're dangerous. A wider tire with a 300-400 rating will hook so much better in all temps.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Craag